Mats Wilander ranks Andy Murray among the game’s greats and assesses his comeback hopes
Tennis legend Mats Wilander believes Andy Murray will struggle to return to the top of the game if he attempts to make a comeback after undergoing hip resurfacing surgery on Monday.
Murray’s long-running battle with a hip problem forced him to concede his career was coming to an end prior to his first-round defeat against Roberto Bautista Agut at the Australian Open, but he will now hope to have a final attempt to return to the top of tennis after his latest surgery.
However, Wilander believes that ambition may be a step too far for the three-time Grand Slam champion, as he suggests the game has moved on to a new level with young guns like Alexander Zverev, Stefanos Tsitispas and Karen Khachanov ready to move up in 2019.
“Another comeback for Murray after surgery may not be realistic,” Eurosport expert Wilander told Tennis365.com in an exclusive interview.
“I think the game is passing him by a little bit. He’s not going to be able to come out and play the way he did in the past because these young guys are going to hit him off the court. There could be days when he wins a match or two because of the other guys’ unforced errors, but there will be a lot of days when he’ll feel outplayed because the other guys over power him. I know that feeling.
“Even players like Novak Djokovic or Roger Federer have experienced this in the last year. There were days when Djokovic felt overpowered by Zverev in London and Khachanov in Paris – they just blew him off the court and he couldn’t compete on these days.
“If Murray does come back, it’s going to be different unless he changes styles, which has happened with Roger and Rafael Nadal too. They’ve become way more aggressive, which is the natural evolution of a tennis player.”
Wilander believes Murray was not fit enough to play at the Australian Open, but he admits coming to terms with retirement is a tough battle for any player.
“I’ve no idea what the thought process was when Murray decided to play in Melbourne,” said Wildander. “It nearly feels like outside pressure bullied him in to feeling like he had to make some kind of decision that he didn’t want to make. I think he felt he had to make a decision rather than stepping away and clearing his head.
“The mistake to me is that clearly he’s not mentally done. I realise that physically you can be done, when it’s not on your terms, but mentally you look for other ways. So I think he was bullied in to it because there was this amazing story about the big four being back but really he was not at the level but still playing.”
As seven-time Grand Slam champion Wilander looks to place Murray among the ranks of the all-time greats, he has no doubt the Scot deserves a special place in tennis history after achieving so much during an era when the competition was at its strongest.
“He’s a top 20 player of all time, for sure,” he added. “His achievements of winning two Olympic titles, in an era where players really wanted to win it, and three majors, with the guys he was surrounded by, is a great achievement.”
Follow Kevin Palmer on Twitter @RealKevinPalmer
More from Tennis365:
Rafael Nadal stunned by former world No 12 Borna Coric in Cincinnati: ‘I won, it’s kind of crazy’
Delight for Borna Coric as he upsets Rafael Nadal in Cincy.
Exclusive – Tim Henman backing Emma Raducanu after her stunning return to form
Tim Henman has told Tennis365 that Emma Raducanu will stun the sporting world once again
Emma Raducanu blows past former World No 1 to reach last 16 in Cincy
Emma Raducanu was clearly the better player as she claimed her first win over a top 20 player since her US Open title run.
Andy Murray hit by cramps again Cameron Norrie scrapes battle of the Brits
Andy Murray claimed the opening set but Cameron Norrie saved nine break points and downed the former World No 1.
US Open wildcards: Venus Williams and Dominic Thiem handed slots
Williams, who won at Flushing Meadows in 2000 and 2001, will compete at the age of 42.
ATP Race to Turin: How things stand as tour rolls into Cincy
The ATP Race to Turin is getting tight.
Rafael Nadal cautious but excited ahead of ATP Tour return
Rafael Nadal says that he ‘has to be careful’.
Gael Monfils’ injury woes continue as he withdraws from US Open
Gael Monfils ruled out of another Grand Slam.
Emma Raducanu urged to stick with Dmitry Tursunov by former British No 1: ‘Her tactics were good’
Emma Raducanu and Dmitry Tursunov off to a good start in Cincy.
Simona Halep hits $40m mark in WTA career-prize money earnings, only behind Serena and Venus Williams
A look at where Simona Halep sits on some of the all-time WTA lists.