T365 Recall: When the Madrid Open’s blue ‘Smurf’ clay courts irked the tennis community
Madrid Open owner Ion Tiriac is a man who is not afraid to push the boundaries when it comes to tennis traditions. He is, after all, a businessman. However, his 2012 Madrid Open blue ‘Smurf’ clay idea didn’t go down well with the tennis fraternity.
Under Tiriac’s leadership in 2004, the tournament replaced traditional ball boys and ball girls with fashion models and, naturally, it ruffled some feathers.
Clearly not put off by the disapproval the models received, Tiriac and the Madrid Open organisers again came up with a bizarre proposal in 2012: blue clay courts.
The tournament had been played on outdoor red clay since 2009, but Tiriac decided it was time for a change.
Again it was a decision that did not go down well with the players with local hero Rafael Nadal tweeting: “It’s a lack of respect for tradition and the history of this area, I hope one day not having to play on blue grass.”
The criticism didn’t die down when the tournament got underway as many players felt it was too slippery and they didn’t enjoy playing on the surface.
Here’s what some of the players said or tweeted.
“I haven’t heard a single player, not man or woman, saying they like blue clay.” – Novak Djokovic
“After playing a match on blue clay court 6 I can say with full responsibility on my shoulders that it is the worst court of @ATPWorldTour.” – Ukrainian player Sergiy Stakhovsky
“Ha! Blue clay… It looks like something Smurfs would play on.” – Croatian player Ivo Karlovic
“It’s not so much about the colour, it does look good on television. But it plays a bit different, it’s about the amount of clay on the court and the way it bounces. It’s just a matter of adjusting. It’s also the same for everyone.” – Maria Sharapova
“Hitting on the Smurf clay, the bounce is lower and the two courts I practiced on were a bit more slippery than usual.” – Milos Raonic
“I haven’t noticed a difference between the blue and the red clay. I think it’s the same. It’s just you don’t get as dirty.” – Serena Williams, who went on to win the tournament with a two-set win over Victoria Azarenka in the final.
“Next time I have to bring skates instead of shoes, it was sooo slippery,” Djokovic said after his first-round match, but he was a little more outspoken after he lost in the second round as he threatened to boycott the event if they didn’t switch back to red clay.
“It took me at least a week to try to get used to this surface and somehow find a way to win matches and play a decent level of tennis. There is no discussion in my eyes, it’s very simple. No blue clay for me.”
Nadal was another early casualty and he also warned that he would not return if they stuck with the blue clay.
“I tried my best to prepare but I wasn’t good enough to adapt my game to this court,” the Spaniard said. “The only thing that I know is that if things continue like this I am very sad but next year will be one less tournament in my calendar.”
With his two main rivals exiting early, Roger Federer went on to win the title as he beat Tomas Berdych in three sets to win the tournament for a third time.
Thankfully the organisers came to their senses and switched back to the traditional red clay in 2013. Well, they were forced as the ATP outlawed blue clay courts.
“After careful consideration, I have decided that blue clay courts will not be allowed next year. I very much believe in innovation and exploring ways to enhance our sport. While the blue clay may have offered better visibility on television, there were clearly issues with the quality of the courts in Madrid this year …” Executive Chairman and President Brad Drewett said in a statement.
“Regardless of color, we must first ensure that courts are safe and fair for players,” he added.
Tiriac, though, hasn’t given up on the idea as in 2016 he made it clear that “we hope to have blue clay again”.
“You could see ball much better, the only problem was that players were sliding much, but they never complained about the colour,” the Romanian said. “TVs and players agreed with the fact that you could see the ball better. We hope to have blue clay again, everyone wants it.”
Nick Kyrgios snaps back after being branded “evil” and “a bully” by Stefanos Tsitsipas
The main interview room at Wimbledon was…
Nick Kyrgios roadshow rumbles on at Wimbledon as he beats Stefanos Tsitsipas in bad-tempered thriller
Nick Kyrgios knocked out Stefanos Tsitsipas in the third round.
Rafael Nadal sees off Lorenzo Sonego and insists there was nothing ‘spicy’ about net conversation
Rafael Nadal marches on at Wimbledon.
Iga Swiatek philosophical after her incredible streak ends with Wimbledon exit
Iga Swiatek seeing her glass as half full.
Cameron Norrie on facing Tommy Paul at Wimbledon: ‘Good friends off the court, but it’s going to be a battle’
Norrie takes on his practice partner in the fourth round at Wimbledon.
Alize Cornet after snapping Iga Swiatek’s 37-match winning streak: ‘Good wine always ages well’
Alize Cornet is aging like a fine wine as the veteran upset Iga Swiatek at Wimbledon.
Amanda Anisimova sees off Coco Gauff at Wimbledon for ‘most special day of my career’
Gauff failed to make the fourth round on her third appearance at the Championships.
Impressive Alex De Minaur ends Liam Broady’s Wimbledon journey in third round
World No132 joined compatriot Katie Boulter in bowing out on day six of the Championships.
Katie Boulter ’emotionally drained’ as she admits Harmony Tan match was ‘one step too far for me’
It has been an emotional week for Boulter following the death of her grandmother.
Tatjana Maria keeps daughter happy with Wimbledon run, but hopes to help next generation of WTA moms
The mum-of-two beat Maria Sakkari to secure a maiden fourth-round appearance at a major.