Comment: Umpire Carlos Ramos was right to ‘go for the jugular’ in US Open final
It wasn’t pretty, it won’t have won him any fans, in fact he is likely to receive a torrent of abuse, but chair umpire Carlos Ramos was left with little choice but to ‘go for the jugular’ during the controversial US Open final.
Quite a few former players and pundits believe Ramos should have tried to manage the situation and instead just given Serena Williams a warning about crossing the line during the match against Naomi Osaka.
“Because of the big occasion – finals, the score, a game penalty – he should have warned her,” Chris Evert told BBC Radio 5 live.
“Scold her. ‘Ms Williams you need to be quiet because if you keep going on like this it will be a game.’
“Because of the enormity of the moment he should have given her a little bit of a break – but instead he just went right for the jugular.”
But the damage had already been done, Williams had already crossed the line and as there were three clear strikes against the American.
By the letter of the law, he was right to penalise Serena Williams on all three occasions, US Open final or no US Open final.
The drama unfolded when the 23-time Grand Slam winner was given a code violation early in the second set for coaching by Patrick Mouratoglou.
If the umpire decides that there was coaching, then it is a black and white decision.
“Players shall not receive coaching during a match (including the warm-up). Communications of any kind, audible or visible, between a player and a coach may be construed as coaching.”
That is what the official wording about coaching during Grand Slams.
And while Williams insisted she wasn’t coached, Mouratoglou put an end to the matter.
“I was coaching but I don’t think she looked at me,” Mouratoglou said. “Sash [Osaka’s coach Sascha Bajin] was coaching as well. Everybody does it.”
Patrick Mouratoglu admits to coaching Serena Williams in US Open final defeat.https://t.co/fS0BWmCVDD
— Tennis365 (@T365Official) September 8, 2018
The fact that “everybody does it” doesn’t make it right.
A few games later and Williams took her frustration out on her racket and again Ramos was justified in giving her a second violation and a point penalty.
“Abuse of rackets or equipment is defined as intentionally, dangerously and violently destroying or damaging racquets.”
Instead of using her experience and keep control, Williams allowed her emotions to get the better of her.
With Osaka leading 4-3, she lost it as she accused the umpire of “lying”.
“You are a liar. You will never be on a court of mine as long as you live. When are you going to give me my apology? Say you are sorry,” she shouted at the official.
VIDEO: Serena Williams rages at chair umpire over coaching accusations.https://t.co/CwvFXKmROo
— Tennis365 (@T365Official) September 8, 2018
And again, umpire Ramos didn’t have much of an option as she was docked the next game.
“Verbal abuse is defined as a statement about an official, opponent, sponsor, spectator or other person that implies dishonesty or is derogatory insulting or otherwise.”
Otherwise, where do you draw the line when it comes to abuse of officials?
You just can’t have players going off like that, we see it happen a lot in football and it’s not a pretty sight.
Earlier in the tournament chair umpire Mohamed Lahyani was criticised after his on-court pep talk to Nick Kyrgios.
Lahyani went “beyond protocol” after he stepped down from his chair to speak to the Australian about his performance.
Ramos would not have quite gone “beyond protocol”, but you can’t have your bread buttered on both sides and want one umpires to “stick to the letter of the law”, but on the other side you want them to manage situations.
Unfortunately, it is all down to Williams as she allowed the situation to get out of control. Many a player has been given code violations, but simply got their heads down and got on with it.
Andy Murray comes up short in his quarter-final clash in Metz
Murray was beaten by top seed Hubert Hurkacz at the Moselle Open in Metz
Big change in Emma Raducanu’s camp as she seeks to make key appointment
Raducanu is preparing to make big changes to the team she will be working with after confirming she is on the look-out for a new coach.
Emma Raducanu to be given ‘homecoming’ broadcast to toast her US Open win
The Lawn Tennis Association are set to give Emma Raducanu the welcome home she deserves.
Exclusive – Assessing Novak Djokovic’s legacy with one of the game’s leading writers
Novak Djokovic has always been fighting a losing battle in a popularity contest with Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal.
Emma Raducanu could secure a place in lucrative end-of-season WTA finals
Raducanu could be on course to secure a remarkable place in the lucrative end-of-season WTA finals in Mexico.
Andy Murray eyeing up leap in the rankings after another win in Metz
Murray is one win away from a return to the top 100 in the ATP rankings.
Emma Raducanu confirms first sponsorship deal and plenty more will follow
The sponsorship opportunities are rolling in for…
‘Winning is what sport is all about’ – Andy Murray reacts to one of his best wins of 2021
The former world number dispatched the home favourite favourite 4-6 6-3 6-2.
Andy Murray accepts wildcard as he prepares to return to scene of one of his great wins
Murray completed a comeback few believed was possible when he won the ATP event in Antwerp in 2019.
Coaching guru insists Emma Raducanu still has much to prove after US Open win
She is the new queen of tennis…