Rafael Nadal v Chris Evert: Who is the real clay court greatest of all time?

With the clay-court season in full swing and approaching the French Open, Rafael Nadal is getting widely hailed as the greatest player of all time on the red dirt.
It’s tough to argue, however there is one other player who makes a very serious challenge for the title of best clay-court player the game has ever seen: Chris Evert.
So, let’s see if we can settle this.
The head-to-head statistics
In many ways it’s hard to compare here.
Evert played on the WTA circuit and Nadal the ATP. Evert played in the 70s and 80s when wooden rackets ruled and athleticism was winged to a certain extent, whereas Nadal plays in the era of the sports science specialist.
That said, the comparison is useful if for nothing else but to see just how similar their respective records read.
Nadal has more French Open titles but Evert has more clay-court titles overall. Nadal has won more matches but Evert has a better win percentage. Every argument essentially has a counter-argument to answer.
The case for Evert
There are many reasons to back Evert in this debate.
Her unerring accuracy from the baseline and beautiful two-handed backhand made her a genuine joy to watch – and nightmare to play – on clay.
She won 125 matches in a row before a young Tracy Austin stopped her – a streak that lasted six years.
She won more French Open titles than any other woman to date and has more clay-court titles than any other woman. If you want some context on that issue, her 66 clay-court titles is more than double the amount that Steffi Graf (32) managed.
However, Martina Navratilova may be the biggest reason why Evert deserves the title. It took Navratilova – a serve and volley specialist, admittedly, but good enough to win two French Opens – a whole decade to get the best of Evert on the red dirt.
The case for Nadal
Well, a bit awkwardly, Chris Evert has cast her own vote in this and gone for Nadal, but we’re putting that down to a little humility.
Congrats to @RafaelNadal , the greatest clay courter ever; enjoy ur big win!!!
— Chris Evert (@ChrissieEvert) June 9, 2014
The truth is, though, that Nadal needs no endorsements to stake his claim to be heralded as the greatest-ever clay court player.
His record speaks for itself, as does his actual brilliance, especially that topspin forehand that rockets up off the surface like a leaping predator. He plays left-handed too, which gives his opponents an extra nightmare.
It’s quite annoyingly easy to dismiss the Roger Federer factor given his reluctance to play clay-court season these days when discussing Nadal. The Swiss isn’t known for his prowess on clay so dominating him on the surface is perhaps not the boast it should be.
Almost certainly, though, Federer’s record on clay would be much better had he not played in the Nadal era.
He has lost four finals at Roland Garos alone – all of them to the Spaniard, and dominating a player of that quality must surely make a colossal case alone for Nadal in this argument.
Who is the greatest of all time on clay? We’ll leave it to you to decide but feel free to leave us your views or on our social media channels!
Latest
-
Tennis News
Former world No 1 urges Australian public to give Novak Djokovic ‘another chance to explain himself’
“He was being a leader and it just came off wrong in the public.”
-
Tennis News
Ashleigh Barty happy to ‘knuckle down’ and get back into routine ahead of Australian Open
Ashleigh Barty ready for her big comeback.
-
Australian Open
2021 Australian Open prize money breakdown: Smaller cheques for winners, boost for first-round losers
A look at the 2021 Australian Open prize money.
-
Tennis News
Nick Kyrgios ‘very misunderstood’, but he will ‘always have your back’, says fellow Australian
“We’re almost brothers – pretty close.”
-
Tennis News
Changes made to ATP and WTA schedules to aid those affected by quarantine
Players will also be given priority for gyms and ice baths.
-
Australian Open
Boris Becker on what happens next for Alexander Zverev after a turbulent 2020
Boris Becker backs Alexander Zverev to win maiden major.
-
Australian Open
Dominic Thiem dismisses calls for the Australian Open to be cancelled
Dominic Thiem insists Australian Open should go ahead.
-
Tennis News
Timeline of Andy Murray’s injury nightmare as he pulls out of Australian Open
A timeline of Andy Murray’s injury woes since 2017.
-
News
Andy Murray ‘gutted’ as he shelves plans to play at Australian Open
Murray has been unable to solve a quarantine conundrum.
-
ATP Tour
Novak Djokovic and Rafael Nadal learn their fate in ATP Cup draw
Serbia will begin defence of ATP Cup against Germany and Canada.