Jannik Sinner and Novak Djokovic comparison throws up huge talking point
Is Jannik Sinner playing at a better level than Novak Djokovic in his prime?
Mats Wilander kick-started this debate when he suggested Sinner and his young rival Carlos Alcaraz were playing tennis at a level above the ‘Big 3’ of Roger Federer, Rafael Nadal and Novak Djokovic in their prime.
Considering those players have won a stunning 66 Grand Slam titles between them, such a claim was always likely to raise eyebrows, but now it has been backed up by a couple of current top ten players.
American Taylor Fritz suggested that Sinner and Alcaraz are playing at a level that makes them harder to play against than the ‘Big 3’ as he offered up these comments to the Tennis Channel.
“One thing both of those guys do is… their defence is incredible,” said Fritz.
“They don’t really play that much defence. When they are full on the run out in the corners, they just crush the ball.
“I can be in a backhand cross (court) rally with either one of them and if I hit a forehand, it’s got to be so good or else that next ball is getting just drilled huge cross court.
“They just play these lateral baseline points… like we used to see Nadal and Fed and most you saw Nadal and Novak have these long points, corner to corner.
“When Sinner and Alcaraz do it corner to corner, they have these same rallies but I swear they are hitting the ball ten miles an hour faster. It’s just crazy.”
Now Ruud has backed up those comments from Fritz with some detailed analysis of how it feels to take on Sinner after he was crushed 6-1, 6-2 by the Italian in an ATP Finals last four match in Turin.
The intensity of Sinner’s ball striking, the punch he now has on his serve and the level of consistency he can operate at makes the world No 1 a real handful for any opponents and when asked to compare Djokovic and Sinner, Ruud went into surprising detail as he gave his verdict.
“In my opinion, because they play different tennis,” said the Norwegian.
“I mean, I think on TV it looks probably similar the way they play. But Jannik hits a faster ball than Novak. He doesn’t let you breathe.
“With Novak you can play rallies. Not going to say easier to play Novak because he’s the best in the history. At least with Novak you can play more rallies and not be terrified of Novak ripping, like, a bomb down the line or cross-court or these things.
“I don’t necessarily like to compare players because everyone has their own style. For me, you don’t realize how fast Jannik plays unless you watch him play live and you’re there in the stadium. On the TV, it’s not fair, the speed.
“I got to practice with him here earlier leading up to the tournament. He also kicked my ass there. In a way, I knew what I was facing today. Sometimes you feel like players might play even better in practice because they play with no pressure and such things. But today he played really well from the beginning until the end.
More Tennis News
ATP Finals: The 6 men to reach the most finals – ft. Roger Federer, Novak Djokovic
The 5 oldest ATP Finals champions: Novak Djokovic features twice, Roger Federer 3rd
“I mean, I didn’t get a good start so I get stressed and overplay a bit. Even the points I played really well, he was there defending well. I ended up doing a stupid mistake at the end.
“I hope I can play Jannik more in the future ’cause it’s a really fun challenge even though today I lost badly.”
Comparing different eras in any sport is a tough task, but Sinner and Alcaraz are an extension of tennis generations that were dominated by Federer, Nadal and Djokovic.
So it feels easier to draw comparisons between the ‘Big 3’ of the last two decades and the ‘Big 2’ of the current ATP Tour.
Only when Sinner and Alcaraz match the Grand Slam wins and other achievements of the legends that came before them can they be compared favourably to the ultimate giants of the men’s game.
Yet the comments from Fritz and Ruud cement the suspicion that a new era is now underway in men’s tennis and it offers up the delicious potential to be just as glorious as the one that went before.
READ NEXT: Taylor Fritz may regret his Jannik Sinner comments ahead of ATP Finals showdown
